Customers
Sign In
Customers
Sign In

Accounting Automation Services and How to Test the Handoff

Listen to article

4:52

When evaluating accounting automation services, ask each provider to show how one workflow moves from source records to your ledger. Give each provider the same sample and ask who owns the mapping, who clears exceptions and what your team can export after a run. Use the results to decide what to include in a pilot.

Start with one handoff, such as approved vendor bills moving into a single entity’s ledger. For related reading on the destination system, see Campfire’s Core Accounting overview.

Key Takeaways

  • Specify which work the provider will configure, which work it will operate and which decisions stay with your finance team.
  • Give every provider the same sample inputs, approval rules and expected ledger output.
  • Ask for an export that ties the source records to posted entries and shows where held items went.

What work should you ask the service to cover?

Define the exact starting point and endpoint of the pilot. For a bill import, start with the file of approved bills and end with the posted ledger entries and a list of held items. Ask the provider to mark each step it will configure, operate or hand back to your team. Ask who owns the mapping after launch and how the provider will hand it back if the engagement ends.

Give the same scope to each provider and ask for separate estimates for setup, ongoing support and changes after launch. In the scope document, say who will take the first look at a rejected item and who can approve a corrected posting. Record the answers next to the quoted work so you can compare the proposals against the same responsibilities.

How do you run a comparable pilot?

Use a fictional batch for a single entity. Bills A and B have approved account mappings and amounts of $140 and $60. Bill C has an amount of $40 and no account mapping. For this pilot, set the expected result at two posted bills totaling $200 and one held bill for $40. Tell each provider that replaying this specific batch should create no extra entries.

Pilot caseExpected result for this sampleWhat to ask the provider to show
Import approved billsExpected result for this sampleA and B post for a total of $200What to ask the provider to showSource IDs, ledger IDs and applied account mappings
Import the bill without a mappingExpected result for this sampleC stays held for $40What to ask the provider to showReason for the exception and the person assigned to handle it
Replay the same fileExpected result for this sampleZero additional postingsWhat to ask the provider to showReplay history and unchanged ledger entries

Save the expected results before the pilot. Ask the provider to explain discrepancies against those results using the run history. Record what the provider demonstrated separately from what it proposed to configure later, then schedule a repeat test for any change you agree to include.

What records should you ask to take away?

The IRS recordkeeping guidance[c1] says businesses can select a recordkeeping system suited to them that clearly shows income and expenses. Ask for a copy of the pilot exports and check whether your team can trace a bill from the input file to the ledger and find its approval or exception history.

In its standard on using service organizations, PCAOB AS 2601, paragraph .12[c2] gives reconciliation of a service organization’s output reports with source documents as one example of a user organization control. If that kind of reconciliation is relevant to your audit, bring the pilot’s source file and output to your auditor to discuss what evidence they would need.

For related reading on the workflows you might evaluate next, see Campfire’s Accounting Intelligence overview. Scope the next test independently with its own expected results.

Conclusion

Ask each provider to demonstrate the same workflow with the same expected results. Keep the mapping, exception history, ledger output and scope proposal together so you can compare the handoffs. Bring your sample when you get started with Campfire.

FAQ

What should the provider demo include?

Ask to see a successful import, a held item and a replay of the same file. Ask the provider to show the result from the source input through the ledger or the exception queue.

How can we compare different implementation proposals?

Give providers the same sample, scope and expected results. Compare their demonstrated output and the responsibilities each proposal assigns to the provider and to your finance team.

What if the provider cannot export the trial results?

Record the export as an open requirement for the pilot. Ask the provider to name the available export formats and identify how your team could match the trial’s sources, ledger entries and exceptions.

Sources

  1. [c1] Recordkeeping | Internal Revenue Service — irs.gov. Accessed November 17, 2026.
  2. [c2] AS 2601: Consideration of an Entity's Use of a Service Organization | PCAOB — pcaobus.org. Accessed November 17, 2026.